Key West, Florida, is a vibrant island city known for its lively atmosphere, beautiful sunsets, and eclectic dining scene. Whether you’re a foodie or just looking for a great meal, Key West offers an array of dining options that cater to all tastes. From waterfront seafood spots to historic cafes, here are ten of the best places to eat in Key West.
Blue Heaven
Blue Heaven is an iconic Key West restaurant known for its eclectic atmosphere and delicious Caribbean-inspired cuisine. Located in the historic Bahama Village, this quirky eatery offers outdoor seating under a canopy of trees, complete with roosters roaming around. The menu features a mix of fresh seafood, hearty breakfasts, and signature dishes like their famous Key Lime Pie. Live music adds to the vibrant ambiance, making Blue Heaven a must-visit spot.
Santiago’s Bodega
For a unique dining experience, head to Santiago’s Bodega, a tapas-style restaurant perfect for sharing delicious small plates with friends and family. The menu offers a wide selection of Spanish-inspired dishes, from savory lamb patties to bacon-wrapped dates. The cozy, intimate setting makes it an ideal spot for a relaxed meal, and the extensive wine list ensures there’s a perfect pairing for every dish.
Louie’s Backyard
Situated on the waterfront, Louie’s Backyard offers stunning views along with a diverse menu featuring fresh seafood and innovative dishes. This upscale restaurant is divided into several sections, including a fine dining room, a casual deck, and a dockside bar. Signature dishes like the Yellowtail Snapper and the famous Key Lime Pie are not to be missed. The picturesque setting, combined with excellent food and service, makes Louie’s Backyard a top dining destination in Key West.
Latitudes
Located on the private island of Sunset Key, Latitudes offers upscale dining in a picturesque setting with panoramic views of the Gulf of Mexico. Accessible by a short ferry ride, this restaurant serves contemporary American cuisine with an emphasis on fresh, local ingredients. Enjoy dishes like the Lobster Benedict for breakfast or the Filet Mignon for dinner while soaking in the breathtaking sunset views. Reservations are highly recommended for this exclusive dining experience.
Garbo’s Grill
Garbo’s Grill is a hidden gem known for its delicious tacos and Caribbean-inspired flavors. This food truck-turned-restaurant has garnered a loyal following among locals and visitors alike. The menu features a variety of tacos, burritos, and bowls, all made with fresh ingredients and bold flavors. The Korean BBQ Taco and the Umami Burger are particularly popular choices. Despite its casual setting, Garbo’s Grill delivers big on taste and quality.
Pepe’s Cafe
Established in 1909, Pepe’s Cafe is Key West’s oldest restaurant, serving up classic American comfort food in a charming and historic setting. The rustic decor and laid-back vibe make it a favorite among both locals and tourists. The menu includes hearty breakfast options, juicy burgers, and fresh seafood dishes. Pepe’s is also famous for its homemade pies, which are the perfect way to end any meal.
Hogfish Bar and Grill
Nestled in Stock Island, Hogfish Bar and Grill is a laid-back seafood shack known for its signature hogfish sandwich and relaxed atmosphere. This off-the-beaten-path spot offers a true taste of the Florida Keys with its fresh, local seafood and casual, waterfront setting. The menu features a variety of seafood dishes, including conch fritters, fish tacos, and, of course, the must-try hogfish sandwich. It’s a great place to kick back and enjoy a cold drink with friends.
El Siboney
For authentic Cuban cuisine, look no further than El Siboney, a local favorite known for its flavorful dishes and generous portions at affordable prices. This family-owned restaurant offers a taste of Cuba with dishes like Ropa Vieja, Picadillo, and the famous Siboney Steak. The casual, no-frills atmosphere adds to the charm, making it a go-to spot for a satisfying and hearty meal.
Firefly Key West
Firefly Key West offers a cozy ambiance and a Southern-inspired menu, perfect for a relaxed dining experience. Located in a historic building, this restaurant serves comfort food classics with a modern twist. Highlights include the Chicken and Waffles, Shrimp and Grits, and the delectable Pecan Pie. The inviting atmosphere and friendly service make Firefly a great choice for brunch, dinner, or any meal in between.
Half Shell Raw Bar
A Key West institution, Half Shell Raw Bar is beloved for its fresh seafood and casual vibe. Located on the historic seaport, this lively spot offers oysters, clams, and other seafood delights in a no-frills setting. The raw bar is the star of the show, featuring a variety of oysters from both coasts, served fresh on the half shell. The relaxed atmosphere and waterfront views make it a favorite spot for both locals and tourists looking to enjoy some of the best seafood in town.
